Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

St. Peter Menu!

  • View from dining room into the kitchen area
    Slide 1 of 5
  • Gallery Slide 2
    Slide 2 of 5
  • a close up of a pizza
    Slide 3 of 5
  • a Panino With a bag of chips
    Slide 4 of 5
  • a close up of a tray of food
    Slide 5 of 5

    • Starters

    Appetizers .... Munchies or a Meal!

    • Cheeseballs

      Cheeseballs

      Served with Ranch Dressing.

      $9.25

    • Garlic Cheese Bread

      Garlic Cheese Bread

      Served with Marinara Sauce. Add Pepperoni or Italian Sausage for 2.00. Add Jalapenos for 1.00.

      $9.75

    • Quesadillas

      Quesadillas

      Made with Extra Innings’ famous flatbread with Cheddar Cheese, Onions & Peppers. Served with Sour Cream and Salsa.

      $9

      Chicken or Beef Quesadilla $10.50

      Steak or Pulled Pork Quesadilla $12.50

    • Pizza Italiano

      Pizza Italiano

      Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese and Pizza Sauce wrapped in our famous flatbread. Served with a side of Ranch.

      $9

    • Nacho Grande

      Nacho Grande

      Corn Chips topped with Creamy Queso, Choice of Beef or Chicken, Jalapeño Peppers, Onions, Black Olives, Lettuce & Tomatoes. Served with a side of Salsa & Sour Cream.

      Single Order $13

    Wings!

    Extra Innings offers Wing Flavors for every sports fan. | Each order comes with our own Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing and Celery Sticks. | Over 1/2 pound of Boneless Wings. Single Order-10

    • Sauces

      Mild

      Medium

      HOT!

      Sweet & Spicy

      Honey

      Honey BBQ

      Honey Mustard

      Teriyaki

      Garlic Herb

      Spicy BBQ

      Garlic Parmesan

    • Dry Rub

      Buffalo

      Lemon Pepper

      Salt & Vinegar

    Paninos

    A unique rolled sandwich filled with lean meats, vegetables and/or cheese, made on our famous homemade flatbread.

     $2.00 fee to split in two, this includes an extra side, pickle and dressing as described in the menu.
     Add a Side Salad for $3.50. 

    • The Betty

      Your choice of Tender Chicken or Turkey, Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese, Fresh Lettuce and Tomatoes, and Ranch Dressing.

      H $7.50

      F $12

    • Marinara Pie

      Spaghetti Noodles, Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese, Choice of Meatballs or Breaded Chicken Breast. Smothered in Marinara and Parmesan Cheese.

      H $8.75

      F $12.25

    • Reuben

      Classic Corned Beef and Sauerkraut topped with Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese. Your choice of Thousand Island or Spicy Mustard.

      H $8.50

      F $13

    • Philly Steak

      Tender Steak Strips, Fresh Mushrooms, Onions, Bells Peppers with Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese and Creamy Queso.

      H $9

      F $16

    • 3 Meat BBQ

      Loaded with Roast Beef, Ham, Chicken, Mozzarella & Provolone and Dripping in BBQ Sauce.

      H $8.75

      F $15

    • The Club

      The Club

      Loaded with Turkey, Ham, Bacon, Cheddar, Broccoli Florets, Crisp Lettuce, Tomatoes and Mayo.

      H $8

      F $14

    • Buffalo Chicken

      Buffalo Chicken

      Once you try it you’ll be hooked! Tender Chicken, Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese, and Celery. Your choice of any of our 12+ Wing Sauces with either Ranch or Bleu Cheese.

      H $7.50

      F $12

    • Taco

      Seasoned Beef or Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives, Fresh Lettuce and Tomatoes. Served with Sour Cream and Salsa.

      H $8

      F $13.50

    • Hawaiian

      A Luau in your mouth! Ham, Onions, Bell Peppers, Pineapple, Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese and Honey Mustard.

      H $8.50

      F $13.50

    • Chicken Cordon Bleu

      Chicken, Ham, Broccoli, Mozzarella, Provolone & Cheddar Cheese and Extra Innings’ Homemade Bleu Cheese Dressing.

      H $8

      F $13

    • Cuban

      Smoked Pulled Pork, Ham, Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese, Pickles and Spicy Mustard.

      H $10

      F $15

    • Steak & Cheese

      Tender Steak Strips, Loaded with Mozzarella, Provolone & Cheddar Cheese and Crisp Lettuce.

      H $9

      F $16

    • Fajita

      Seasoned Steak or Chicken with Onions, Bell Peppers, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce and Tomatoes.

      Chicken H $8

      Chicken F $13

      Steak H $10

      Steak F $16

    • Southwest

      A Mustang Favorite! Chicken or Steak, Bacon, Onions, Bell Peppers and Lettuce with Extra Innings’ own Mustang Sauce.

      Chicken H $8

      Chicken F $13

      Steak H $10

      Steak F $16

    • Chicken Caesar

      Tender Chicken, Mozzarella, Provolone & Parmesan Cheese, Crisp Romaine Lettuce, Tomatoes and Caesar Dressing.

      H $7.50

      F $12

    • Alfredo Pie

      Fettuccine Noodles and Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese with Alfredo Sauce with your choice of Chicken, Popcorn Shrimp or Veggie.

    • No Meat

      H $8.25

      F $12

    • Chicken

      H $9.25

      F $14

    • Popcorn Shrimp

      H $10

      F $15.50

    • Home Run Panino Sampler

      Home Run Panino Sampler

      Chose any 4 Paninos for your perfect Sampler Platter. Cut into 1/3 size for easy sharing. Comes with your choice of side. Feeds 4-6ppl.

      $40

    Build Your Own Panino

    Create your own Crazy Panino with up to 5 toppings. Additional toppings extra.

    • Build Your Own Panino

      H $9.25

      F $12.25

      Additional toppings extra.

    a close up of food

    Salads

    Download PDF

    • Our Selection of Dressings

      Balsamic Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese, Caesar, Creamy Italian, Fat Free Ranch, French, Honey Mustard, Ranch, Thousand Island

    • Add Our Homemade Breadsticks to any Salad Served with Marinara, Alfredo Sauce or Ranch Dressing.

      2 for $2.50

      4 for $3.50

    • Taco Salad

      Shredded Lettuce, Seasoned Ground Beef or Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives, Tomatoes & Tortilla Chips. Served with Sour Cream and Salsa.

      $12.25

      gluten free

    • Chicken Caesar Salad

      Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Homemade Garlic Flavored Croutons, Tomatoes & Parmesan Cheese.

      $12.25

    • Panino Salad

      Turn your favorite Panino into a salad. Price will mirror Panino price.

    Homemade Pizza

    When we say “Homemade” we mean it! Our 10” Pizzas are made from the same famous dough that we use to make our paninos! Choose our Classic Cracker Crust or upgrade to Hand-Tossed for $1!

    Build Your Own Pizza

    Pepperoni, Sausage, Chicken, Turkey, Canadian Bacon, Ground Beef, Roast Beef, Jalapeños, Pineapple, Tomatoes, Onions, Bell Peppers, Mushrooms, Broccoli, Green Olives, Black Olives, Mozzarella Cheese & Cheddar Cheese. Your choice of Pizza, Alfredo, or Garlic Butter Sauce. | $7.99 single topping, Additional toppings extra.

    • Grand Slam

      Loaded with our House Recipe Deutz Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Ground Beef, Ham & Bacon topped with Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese.

      $12.50

    • Cooperstown

      House Recipe Duetz Italian Sausage, Onions, Mushrooms and Green Peppers topped with Mozzarella & Provolone Cheese.

      $12.50

    • Mac & Cheese

      Macaroni & Cheese on a Pizza? It’s delicious!

      $9

    • Taco Pizza

      Seasoned Beef or Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives, Onions & Tortilla Chips topped with Lettuce & Tomatoes. Served with a side of Sour Cream & Salsa.

      $12.50

    • White Chicken Pizza

      Alfredo Sauce, Chicken, Broccoli, Mozzarella Cheese & Fresh Tomatoes.

      $9

  • Gallery Slide 1
    Slide 1 of 2
  • Gallery Slide 2
    Slide 2 of 2

    • Try one of our delicious Rice Bowls! A great option for those rare days when you’re not craving a Panino! 

    Rice Bowls

    Awesome, Fresh, Yummy! Our Rice Bowls are a great option for those rare days you’re not craving a Panino

    • Burrito Bowl

      Cilantro Lime Rice, Seasoned Black Beans, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Creamy Queso Blanco

      $9

      Add Seasoned Chicken or Beef $2

      Add Seasoned Pork or Steak $3

    • Teriyaki Bowl

      Rice, Bell Peppers, Carrots, Cabbage, Pineapples, Onions & Teriyaki Sauce.

      $9

      Add Chicken $2

      Add Steak $3

    • BBQ Bowl

      Rice, Black Beans, Diced Sweet Potatoes, Jalapeños, Creamy Queso & BBQ Sauce.

      $9

      Add Chicken $2

      Add Pulled Pork or Steak $3

    BBQ Rice Bowl

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!