128 W Main Street, Marshall, MN 56258 Open Daily 11am – 11pm MVP Club — Free to Join Marshall's Favorite for 20+ Years 507.532.4714 Fundraising for Local Teams & Schools Dozens of Places to Get a Burger — Only One Place to Get a Panino 128 W Main Street, Marshall, MN 56258 Open Daily 11am – 11pm MVP Club — Free to Join Marshall's Favorite for 20+ Years 507.532.4714 Fundraising for Local Teams & Schools Dozens of Places to Get a Burger — Only One Place to Get a Panino
Marshall, Minnesota · Est. 20+ Years

Only One
Place to Get
a Panino.

Dozens of places to get a burger. But there's only one Extra Innings — Marshall's original Panino, made fresh for over 20 years.

Order Online Join MVP Club
Online Ordering

Your Panino,
Ready When
You Are.

01
Browse & Build
Choose from our full menu of Paninos and sides. Customize everything exactly the way you want it.
02
Place Your Order
Checkout online in seconds. Secure, fast, and simple — no account required.
03
Pick Up Fresh
Walk in, grab your order, and you're out the door. Hot, fresh, and ready.
Start Your Order →
Loyalty Program

The MVP
Club.

Our free rewards program for Extra Innings regulars. Sign up once and start earning — exclusive deals, early access to new menu items, and rewards on every single order.

Exclusive Member Deals
Discounts and promos only available to MVP members.
Early Access
First to know about new menu items and limited specials.
Earn on Every Order
Points add up fast when you're ordering Paninos regularly.
Join Free — MVP Club →
Homer, the Extra Innings Paninos mascot

The best Panino
deserves the best
rewards.

Our Story

Marshall's
Original.

"Dozens of places to get a burger. Only one place to get a Panino."

Extra Innings Paninos has been a Marshall, Minnesota staple for over 20 years. What started as a bold idea — a sandwich unlike anything else in the region — has grown into something people drive, and yes, even fly in for. We've had couples make the trip from Fargo just for a date night Panino.

The Panino isn't a burger. It isn't a regular sandwich. It's a one-of-a-kind creation, built with care, and we'll put ours up against anything. Dozens of places to get a burger — only one place to get a Panino.

Explore the Menu →
Community

Fundraising
for Marshall.

Get Started
Schools & Clubs

Student organizations, booster clubs, and school fundraising events. Easy to set up and your group keeps a real cut of every sale.

Sports Teams

Little league to high school athletics. Extra Innings has always supported Marshall sports — it's in the name.

Local Organizations

Churches, civic groups, and nonprofits — if you're part of the Marshall community, we want to help. Call us to get started.

Quick Answers

Everything
You Need to Know.

A Panino is a hand-crafted sandwich unique to Extra Innings Paninos in Marshall, Minnesota. Unlike standard sandwiches or burgers, the Panino is made with fresh ingredients in the Extra Innings style — the only one of its kind in the region. Dozens of places to get a burger, only one place to get a Panino.
Yes. Extra Innings Paninos offers online ordering directly through this website. Click "Order Online" anywhere on the page to place your order for pickup. Fast, easy, and your food will be hot and ready when you arrive.
The MVP Club is Extra Innings Paninos' free loyalty and rewards program. Members receive exclusive deals, special offers, and early access to new menu items and promotions. It's free to join — just sign up at the MVP Club page.
Extra Innings Paninos is in Marshall, Minnesota. We've been serving the Marshall community for over 20 years. Call us at 507-532-4714 for our current hours and exact address.
Yes! Extra Innings Paninos supports local schools, sports teams, and community organizations through our fundraising program. Visit the Fundraising page or call 507-532-4714 to set up your group's fundraiser.
Extra Innings Paninos is open daily from 11am to 11pm, seven days a week. We're located at 128 W Main Street, Marshall, MN 56258. Call us at 507-532-4714.