Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Our Story

Since 2002 Extra Innings has been serving Marshall the famous Panino! Extra Innings makes every Panino & Pizza fresh to order using premium ingredients, including select locally sourced products. Paninos are not “Fast Food”, they’re Great Food! We continue to evolve, innovate and improve to keep bringing our guests a quality dining experience with choices to make the whole crew happy.

We are fortunate to have become a staple of the Marshall Community. Nothing makes us happier than hearing our friends & family tell us how they just have to bring their friends & family to eat Paninos every time they come to town. 

In December of 2019 we opened our second location in beautiful downtown St. Peter, MN. We are excited to be a part of another great community!

March of 2021 Extra Innings has partnered with The Arlington Dugout in Arlington, MN and is serving their delicious Pizzas there as well! Will there be more to come? We will see!

Remember, there are dozens of places to get a burger, but only one place to get a Panino!

What's a Panino?

A Panino is a unique rolled flatbread sandwich filled with lean meats, cheeses, fresh veggies and tasty sauces. Our dough is made from scratch in house daily. Other places may bake their bread daily, we bake each Panino FRESH TO ORDER!